View profile

DDIntel - The Market’s Game of Musical Chairs: Controversies in Gauge Theory and Economics

DDIntel - The Market’s Game of Musical Chairs: Controversies in Gauge Theory and Economics
By DataDrivenInvestor • Issue #41 • View online

In many ways, the stock market’s movements can be thought of as a game of musical chairs. While the music is playing, everyone is having a good time, but when the music stops, well, someone is going to get caught with their pants down. As Warren Buffet likes to put it, “Only when the tide goes out do you discover who’s been swimming naked.”
It may seem confusing to compare the stock market, a game of up and down, with musical chairs, a game of spinning multi players, but the connection (pun intended) can be made through gauge theory. In physics, a gauge theory is a type of field theory in which the dynamics of the system itself is invariant to local transformations.
Gauge theory can be described as the next evolution of calculus. So the question naturally arises, shouldn’t economics incorporate gauges into theory? After all, mathematical economics “hit an insurmountable wall” and came to the conclusion that stable preferences must be assumed to do any economics, at least according to Gary Becker in 1976.
Fast forward to 1996, economist Pia Malaney and mathematician Eric Weinstein proposed a solution for how to incorporate gauge theory into economics by looking at issues in index number theory, a mathematical problem at the core of measuring inflation. In short, 
“By using techniques developed in differential geometry, it is shown that the so-called index number problem can be resolved by the development of a special economic derivative operator constructed for this purpose.” - Pia Malaney
Coincidentally, in the same year,
“five economists, known as the Boskin Commission, were tasked with saving the government $1 trillion. They observed that if the CPI were lowered by 1.1 percent, then a $1 trillion could indeed be saved over the coming decade. So what did they do? They proposed a way to alter the formula that would lower the CPI by exactly that amount!” - Slate
So, the Boskin Commission ignored this incredible opportunity to accelerate the scientific field of economics by adopting gauge theory, and instead chose to make the politically expedient decision to appease the powers that be.
Rewind back to the 1970s, when Becker was rising to prominence, an NSA code breaker, now known as the “greatest investor on Wall Street”, James Simons, developed the Chern-Simons Theory, a revolution in gauge theory.
“The shocking discovery that emerged from these talks was that both geometers and quantum theorists had independently gotten hold of different collections of insights into a common structure that each group had independently discovered for themselves.” - Eric Weinstein
Correlated, but likely causal, James Simons went on to crack the commodities, but his ambition for equities was unparalleled. Using insights from technical analysis, mathematical physics, and even artificial intelligence, Simons’ Medallion Fund returned annual rates of ~70% since inception, netting investors 40% after factoring in exorbitant, but justified, fees.
Economists are slowly waking up to the fact that this cannot be explained by market efficiency. And while some believe this must be evidence of a Ponzi Scheme, Simons was actually one of the first to alert Madoff’s activities to authorities.
Perhaps the reason for Simons’ success is equally implausible to that of the most successful scam in history; the discovery and creation of superintelligence. But that is a topic for a later discussion.
The bottom line is that Simons’ mathematical genius is the reason for M’s success. And economists would be wise to heed his guidance, by incorporating gauge theory into economics. From changing preferences to changing bundles, gauge theory creates a natural language to extend the scope of economics.
But the mainstream hasn’t been so quite too keen to adopt Malaney and Weinstein’s approach of “how the notion of “path dependence” in Yang-Mills theory might be used to construct a better measure of how cost of living changes over time.”
In November of 2021, Malaney and Weinstein gave a talk at the Money and Banking Workshop hosted by University of Chicago titled “Economics as Gauge Theory”.
Research Engineer at Deepmind, Timothy Nguyen, concluded “the main contribution of the Malaney-Weinstein work is that it provides a striking example of how to obscure simple concepts through an uneconomical use of gauge theory.”
This is not to dispute any of Nguyen’s points; that is beyond the mathematical abilities of the author. Nevertheless, instead of taking this opportunity to simply educate economists and mathematicians about the beauty, power, and potential of Gauge Theory, critics are simply scoring social media points about who’s math is more coherent to an extremely niche audience.
In conclusion, if one wants to understand economics better than anyone alive, look to James Simons. But the market’s game of musical chairs is sure to leave more than a few holding the bag in the short term with its twister of monetary swirls. The controversies of incorporating gauge theory into economics continues.
This week’s DDIntel tries to guide investors through Turbulent TimesThe Monetary SingularityOpen Source Exploitation, and more. Whether it’s time to upgrade your options strategy, learn about causality, or prepare for hardware supply chain disruptions, our intel has you covered.
Bonus material for ML Data Scientists and the Metaverse curious. No crypto this week! We’ve covered enough lately and will be doing an in depth intel soon. Sneak peak is we’re long term believers, but there may be short term pain ahead as crypto capitulates, and bitcoin discovers who she really is.
Help us grow our platform by subscribing and sharing with friends.
Check out our previous issues. You can also learn how to work with DDI here.
Even in Turbulent Times, Funds Will Keep Funding… | by Marc Patterson | Jun, 2022 | DataDrivenInvestor
Marc Patterson of Bennu Partners opens his article by contrasting many recent proclamations that private market funding is drying up with the fact that Cathie Wood of ARK is planning to launch a partially private fund. His point is that funds will always invest in the right opportunity, even, and arguably especially, in turbulent times.
You Need to Stop Trading Options Like Tastytrade | DataDrivenInvestor
Tastytrade is an excellent resource for beginner and intermediate traders. But some of their strategies can be overly simplistic, and following literally without nuance can be problematic. For a detailed summary of Tastytrade’s approach and how to improve on their strategies, be sure to read Mike Toney-Hoffman’s article.
The Monetary Singularity Approaches | by Peter McClard | Jun, 2022 | DataDrivenInvestor
Philosopher Peter McClard argues that money will one day go extinct. Moreover, the power of money is increasing! “Look no further than the fact that multi-billionaires can now do what it took entire nations to do in the past — create their own space programs.” What will the economists do all day if there’s no money around?
Open Source Exploitation. Open source is not free | by Tom | Jun, 2022 | DataDrivenInvestor
When you think of open source, it kind of warms your heart, right? Decentralized markets swooping in to endogenously solve market failure. But it’s not all butterflies and rainbows in the open source space. The brute commercial fact is that businesses are constantly taking advantage of open source developers. Check out insider Tom’s take.
Identifying Leading Indicators With Granger-causality Test | by David L. | Jun, 2022 | DataDrivenInvestor
We had to feature this article because it’s for anyone with a statistical mind. Whether you are an expert “data mad scientist” like David or a complete newbie, this article covers everything from correlation is not causation (is the dog wagging the tail or the tail wagging the dog?) to Granger Causality Analysis. This extraordinarily detailed article is also accessible to a wider audience. Code included!
Hardware Vulnerability: How Should Startups Cope? | DataDrivenInvestor
We’ve all heard of the supply chain disruptions Covid caused, but many economists never expected this to continue 2 years later with no end in sight! Fortunately, VC Amit Garg walks start ups through how to handle the space. Transparency, Vertical Integration, and Logistics. Check. Check. Check.
How To Invest With A Recession Ahead — Tips from Sequoia Capital
Sequoia Capital was leaked! Or at least so it would seem, after a detailed presentation created by the VC giant appeared online. Management Consultant and Value Investor Thomas Herold summarizes Sequoia’s tips for how to manage a possible recession through ruthless survival of the quickest.
Will The Metaverse’s Investment Hype Die Out? | DataDrivenInvestor
Most investors don’t know what to think about the Metaverse. Is it another fad like crypto that has yet to prove itself? Is it ahead of its time, destined to the waste-bin of history, like Google Glass? Or is it a real, tangible investment opportunity? Well, it’s not exactly real, less David Chalmers dispute. Regardless, if you’re looking for a better understanding of the Metaverse, look no further than multi-media marketing executive Rebecca Barnatt-Smith’s exclusive DDI article.
GPU-Accelerated Data Loading With DALI, Part 2: Pipelines and Data Loaders | by Borna Ahmadzadeh | Jun, 2022 | DataDrivenInvestor
For all those machine learners out there, DDI is honored to publish content of this caliber. This is the kind of content that will last for years as a reference point for those data scientists, machine learning experts, and others using DALI. We end this week’s DDIntel with an encouraging call for more technical coding materials, as this grows our reference base while providing real value for people.
Did you enjoy this issue?

empowerment through data, knowledge, and expertise

In order to unsubscribe, click here.
If you were forwarded this newsletter and you like it, you can subscribe here.
Powered by Revue